Pros and Cons of Copper and Aluminum Wire
lkjlkj
For more information, please visit our website.
Cooper and aluminum are the most common types of metal conductors used in electrical wires. They're efficient, easy to use, and affordable. But each type has its advantages and disadvantages and understanding the best applications for each will help you avoid potential problems down the road.
For example, the cost of copper is often higher than aluminum. If you based your final choice on cost alone, the choice is obvious: aluminum. But what if you also need a versatile option that can withstand the test of time? Copper is most likely your first choice now. Let's dive into the pros and cons of each type.
Read more: Different types of wire
When to use copper wire
Traditionally, copper wire is preferred over aluminum wiring because of its strength and durability over time. Overall, copper conducts electricity better than aluminum, is less likely to corrode, and doesn't expand and contract as much as aluminum.
Copper is also extremely flexible, which is a priority when wiring needs to handle a large loads of electricity at one time. Let's take a look at some of the pros and cons.
Pros of copper wiring
There are many advantages to copper wiring:
- Conductivity. Copper wire is highly conductive and transfers electricity well.
- Tensile strength. Copper wire does not expand and contract as much as other wiring. Its tensile strength allows it to handle wear and tear over time, about 40 percent better than aluminum wiring.
- Higher ampacity. Ampacity is the maximum current a conductor can carry without exceeding its temperature rating. Copper can carry a high current without overheating.
- Versatility. Copper can be formed into very fine wire and can easily be mounted by pulling it through ports and feeders.
- Easy to recycle. Recycling copper wire is not only good for the environment, it's also good to keep the supply moving.
- Better known longevity. Copper does not require much maintenance after its installed.
Cons of copper wire
While copper wire may seem like a superior choice, there are several disadvantages:
- Price. Copper is much more expensive than aluminum, which will increase the overall cost of a project.
- Weight. Copper is heavier than aluminum, so in certain applications, copper can be more complex to install than its lighter weight counterpart, aluminum.
- Theft. Thieves often target copper wire over aluminum wire because it's more expensive than other types of wiring.
- Support. Copper wire requires more support over long distances to keep it in place. On top of paying extra costs to supply copper wire for long distances, you could also end up paying more for installation support.
When to use aluminum wire
Aluminum wiring became popular in the s and s when copper prices soared. Aluminum wiring for commercial buildings generally saves a lot of money, and when properly installed, is extremely safe. But there are some drawbacks. Let's explore the pros and cons.
Pros of aluminum wire
- Lighter weight. Aluminum is a lightweight material that's very flexible. Installs are often faster since wire pulls are much quicker in long runs.
- Less expensive per pound. Aluminum is considerably less expensive than copper, which makes it more desirable to use in large projects where runs span long distances.
Cons of aluminum wire
- Less longevity. Prone to cracking and failure when subject to vibration. Aluminum is also more subject to corrosion than copper, meaning its useful life can be shorter as it becomes brittle and subject to breakage.
- Difficult to solder. Aluminum is difficult to solder, limiting its flexibility. Oxidation on aluminum often inhibits soldering.
- Larger size. Because aluminum conductors are larger than copper conductors, larger raceways are required (and additional costs).
- Potential dangers when use incorrectly. When aluminum is properly installed, it is safe. When it is installed incorrectly, there is a potential risks for fire because expansion and contraction cycles have a larger impact on aluminum and can loosen connections. Normal inspections should be performed.
- Terminal points. Aluminum requires an anti-oxidation compound at each terminal point because it is susceptible to oxidation. Oxidation occurs when it comes into contact with moisture and dissimilar metals.
Can both aluminum and copper wire be used?
There are a few instances where you may consider using both aluminum and copper wire. For instance, if aluminum wire already exists but you want to expand with copper wire, there are specific connectors marked Cu-Al to make the connection.
However, mixing between wires can be tricky. Aluminum wire requires specifically rated devices for outlets and switches. Using other devices poses a risk.
Choosing between copper and aluminum wire
Each project is different, and it may not be cut and dry whether to use aluminum over copper or copper over aluminum. We encourage careful consideration when weighing your options.
If you're still examining factors, contact us to help you with your project. Our team of experts know electrical wire inside and out, and can offer the best solution to fit your needs, while also keeping your budget in mind.
How To Choose The Correct Aluminum Alloy
Series
series alloys are chemically pure (99%+ aluminum) and are commonly available in wire and thin sheets. This series has excellent corrosion resistance, workability, and high thermal and electrical conductivity. , for example, is the go-to choice for high voltage transmission lines and other large-scale electrical products.
Mingda contains other products and information you need, so please check it out.
Series
series alloys are alloyed with copper, which allows the material to be precipitation hardened to strengths near those of steel. This is, however, at the expense of corrosion resistance. was once one of the most common high-strength aerospace alloys, but has been increasingly replaced by series materials which arent as susceptible to stress-corrosion cracking.
Series
Manganese is the alloying element in series aluminums. This alloy has good corrosion resistance and strength, and also performs notably well in stamping applications. This makes it the material of choice for beverage cans, grating, and many types of tubing.
Series
Silicon is used as the main alloying element in series alloys. Silicon improves the fluidity of the material in its molten state which is helpful in products like welding wire and brazing rod.
Series
series aluminum is alloyed mainly with magnesium and silicon, giving it superb corrosion resistance. This is helpful in marine applications where the material is subjected to constant harsh conditions. aluminum is widely known for being one of the easiest alloys to weld. Combine that with the alloys excellent corrosion resistance and you have a perfect material for pressure vessels and ship hulls.
Series
The series materials are alloyed with magnesium and silicon. They are easily machined, weldable, and heat treatable (though not to the same strengths as and series). series alloys like and are extremely common in machining and architectural applications. , for example, is available in almost any shape and size you could imagine including bar, plate, sheet, tube, channel and more.
Series
Zinc is the primary alloying element in series alloys, but magnesium and copper are usually present as well. These materials possess the highest strengths of any of the aluminum alloys. is commonly used in aircraft landing gears and other parts requiring high strength to weight ratios. is another common series alloy and is also heavily used in aerospace applications requiring stress-corrosion resistance.
Temper and Age Conditions
Temper designations tell the material producer and consumer how an alloy has been mechanically and/or thermally modified to achieve certain properties. The first letter designates the class of treatment, while the succeeding number(s) designate specific processes that have been applied to an alloy.
F as fabricated. These are semi-finished products that have not yet been thermally modified.
O annealed. Materials with the O designations have been annealed, usually to maximize workability.
H strain hardened. This is for non-heat-treatable alloys that have had their strength increased by stain hardening. This process, of course, usually does not involve heat as is performed at room temperature.
T thermally treated. This designation represents products that have gone through the entire tempering process. These materials have been given a solution heat treatment followed by quenching and artificial aging.
W solution heat treated. This designation usually represents an unfinished product. Solution heat treating is the process by which a material is heated up and held at a certain temperature for a specified amount of time, and then rapidly cooled to lock in the properties of the heated material. This process is usually followed by tempering and quenching.
Key Takeaways
For an engineer or part designer, series numbers are the most important topic to understand. Temper and age conditions are somewhat set-in stone, and engineers typically dont specify these in the design stage, except in very specific circumstances. For example, if you would like a part to made from aluminum, it is likely going to be of the -T designation. Engineers should also understand the shapes and sizes alloys are available in. McMaster Carr is a good source for this information.
Choosing the correct alloy can have major impacts not only on the performance of your parts, but also on the cost. If you need help selecting the right material for your parts, contact us or get a quote!
The company is the world’s best Aluminium Alloy Cable supplier. We are your one-stop shop for all needs. Our staff are highly-specialized and will help you find the product you need.
Comments
All Comments (0)