The Ultimate Guide to PCB Materials Selection

The Ultimate Guide to PCB Materials Selection

PCB materials, short for Printed Circuit Board materials, are the fundamental components in modern electronics. Whether you're engineering a cutting-edge device or a basic household gadget, choosing the right PCB material is crucial to avoid potential issues. The performance and suitability of electronic devices are significantly influenced by the choice of PCB material.

For more information, please visit INvar Material.

We have conducted comprehensive analyses and tests on a varied array of printed circuit board materials to aid in making an informed selection. Each type of PCB material is crafted to address specific requirements and challenges. So, let's delve into the different materials to find the one that best suits your needs!

The substrate material selection determines the efficiency and attributes of printed circuit boards. Thus, selecting the appropriate materials when designing your circuit board is paramount. Most PCB materials are composed of epoxy resin substrates, glass fiber, and copper foil. Copper is frequently utilized due to its excellent electrical conductivity.

Types of PCB Materials

Here's a breakdown of various types and their distinct advantages. Make informed decisions about your electronics projects.

1. Hard/Rigid Materials

Rigid and ceramic-based materials are essential when you need your circuit board to retain its shape over its lifespan. These materials prevent the board from bending or changing shape. Rigid PCB materials are widely used in producing computer motherboards.

The most common rigid materials are aluminum, aluminum nitride, and beryllium oxide.

Benefits of Rigid Materials

• They can function at temperatures above 3500°C.
• They are compact and integrate effectively with PCB components.
• They possess a high dielectric constant.
• They do not suffer from outgassing issues.
• They exhibit minimal water absorption, allowing for hermetic packaging.

When to Use

• For quick repairs and maintenance, with clearly labeled components.
• To reduce costs in high-volume production runs.
• When a stable board is needed.
• To ensure a clear signal path.

Let's explore the most prevalent types of rigid substrate materials, emphasizing their unique properties, benefits, and challenges.

• FR1 PCB Material

FR1 is a widely utilized PCB material. It consists of a paper substrate with a thin copper layer on a non-conductive phenolic resin. This eco-friendly material complies with ROHS regulations and is notable for its flexibility, ease of processing, and molding, making it ideal for single-sided PCBs. However, it is not suitable for applications involving through-hole components due to its limited heat resistance.

• FR2 PCB Material

Similar to FR1 in usage and cost, FR2 differs in heat resistance, with a lower glass transition temperature (Tg) of 150°C. This makes FR2 less ideal for high-temperature environments.

• FR3 PCB Material

FR3 is another paper substrate material, but it incorporates an epoxy resin. Its epoxy resin compatibility gives it an edge in coating applications, making it suitable for circuit boards requiring coatings.

• FR4 PCB Material

FR4 is a glass-reinforced epoxy resin laminate, renowned for its versatility. It meets the stringent UL94V-0 flame retardant standard, offering excellent adhesion to copper foil, low costs, and superb moisture resistance. It is widely used in double-sided and multi-layer PCBs, including computer motherboards, power supplies, set-top boxes, and Bluetooth audio devices. However, it may not be suitable for high-frequency applications.

• CEM1

Composite Epoxy Material 1 is a low-cost, flame-retardant PCB composite. Combining a glass fabric surface and a paper core with epoxy resin, it offers superior electrical and mechanical properties compared to paper materials like FR1 and FR2, making it ideal for single-sided PCBs with cost-effectiveness as a prime concern.

• CEM2

Composite Epoxy Material 2 is akin to CEM1 but offers higher heat resistance due to its higher Tg value. It is a reliable choice for applications demanding greater heat tolerance, though lacking flame-retardant properties.

• CEM3

Composite Epoxy Material 3 is a copper-clad composite laminate composed of glass fiber cloth and copper foil impregnated with epoxy resin. It serves as a more cost-effective alternative to FR4 and is suitable for double-sided PCBs with plated holes, providing reasonable performance at a lower cost.

• Rogers Material

Rogers material excels in high-frequency applications due to its low electrical signal loss, low dielectric loss, and excellent thermal performance. It is the preferred choice for high-speed designs, RF, microwave, and mobile applications, although it is relatively more expensive than other options.

• Metal Substrates

Metal substrates, including aluminum and copper, are often used in single and double-sided PCBs for their electrical performance, heat dissipation, dielectric strength, and bending resistance. Aluminum substrates are cost-effective and widely used in LED lighting products, while copper substrates, with their high thermal conductivity, are primarily used in specialized applications.

2. Soft/Flexible PCB Materials

Flexible materials offer numerous application possibilities due to their ability to bend, wrap, and fold into various shapes. They have gained popularity in modern consumer electronics over their rigid counterparts.

Flexible materials are particularly useful for electronics that require a bendable PCB during operation without impeding current flow. Industries such as healthcare, smartphones, and wearables have widely adopted flexible PCBs.

Manufacturers often integrate a polyimide film known as Kapton in flexible materials. This film exhibits excellent heat resistance, dimensional stability, and a dielectric property of 3.6. Common flexible PCB materials include polyimide and polytetrafluoroethylene.

The Benefits of Flexible PCB Materials

• They are space-saving and lightweight.
• They ensure good stability by creating a coat near the filler, despite using plastic dielectric materials.
• They reduce PCB sizes, making them suitable for high-signal trace density applications.
• They are ideal for use in harsh environmental conditions as they are waterproof and corrosion-resistant.

When to Use Flexible PCB Materials

• When designing for harsh environments.
• When a miniaturized and lightweight board is required.
• If the application demands a bendable PCB.

Let's explore the primary types of flexible substrate materials, focusing on their unique characteristics, benefits, and challenges.

• PET (Polyester Films)

Polyester films offer flexibility and high chemical and moisture resistance. Typically ranging from 25 to 125 microns in thickness, these films have a melting point of 250°C and a glass transition temperature of 80°C. They are especially suited for applications requiring compact and flexible circuit boards adaptable to tight spaces.

• PI (Polyimide)

Polyimide is a polymer known for its exceptional thermal stability, heat resistance, electrical properties, and chemical resistance, making it ideal for applications exposed to high temperatures and harsh chemicals.

• PTFE (Teflon)

Polytetrafluoroethylene, commonly known as Teflon, is a favored material for flexible circuit boards where temperature stability and low power consumption are critical. Its excellent temperature stability and low dielectric loss make it suitable for applications like cruise control, power amplifiers, and antennas, although it may be costlier than other flexible PCB materials.

3. Flex-rigid PCB Materials

Flex-rigid materials combine soft and hard materials, featuring multiple layers, typically of polyimide. They are used extensively in the aerospace, medical, and military industries for manufacturing circuit boards.

Benefits of Flex-Rigid Materials

• They are easy to machine.
• They are precision-built, suitable for high-precision applications like military and medical equipment.
• They offer a 60% reduction in weight and space.
• They exhibit minimal dielectric losses at microwave frequencies.

When to Use Flex-Rigid Materials

• When lightweight boards are needed.
• When designing boards for medical and military applications.
• For handling relative frequency identification tags.
• In automotive radar and sensor design.
• When designing cellular receivers and power amplifiers.

4. RF-4 PCB Materials

RF-4 is a fiberglass-epoxy material that is cost-effective, an excellent electrical insulator, and more fire-retardant than fiberglass-only materials. Not merely a PCB material, RF-4 is a graded material endorsed by various international trade bodies like NEMA.

FR stands for 'fire retardant,' indicating compliance with the UL94VO standard. FR-4 materials exhibit high flame resistance due to bromine halogens. Multiple sub-grades of FR-4 materials, such as TG130, high TG, and FR4-Rogers, are available.

The Benefits of FR-4

• Cost-effective and versatile.
• Comprising prepreg sheets with fiberglass matting and epoxy resins.
• Representing the electronics industry standard for easy boring and metallization.

When to Use FR-4

• In prototyping.
• For applications with low-speed circuits.
• To minimize production costs.
• In complex designs requiring multiple layers.

Other Specialized PCB Materials Types

While standard PCB materials like FR4 or flexible substrates are suitable for diverse applications, specialized materials are sometimes necessary.

Let's examine a variety of specialized PCB types, each designed for unique applications, tailored for heat dissipation, high-frequency signals, or other specific requirements.

• Metal Core PCBs (MCPCBs)

Metal Core PCBs are built by bonding a metal core, often aluminum, with a dielectric layer and a copper circuit. They excel in high-power LED applications requiring efficient heat dissipation, which extends the lifespan of LEDs. However, MCPCBs may be excessive and costly for low-power, low-heat applications.

• Ceramic PCBs

Ceramic PCBs are made from ceramic materials like aluminum oxide (Al2O3) or aluminum nitride (AlN). They are ideal for high-temperature environments, including power electronics and high-power circuits, due to their heat resistance, thermal conductivity, and electrical insulation properties. However, ceramics may be fragile and costly.

• Teflon PCBs

Teflon PCBs use Polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) as the substrate material. They are valuable for applications demanding low dielectric loss and consistent high-frequency performance. Their exceptional properties make them suitable for specific high-frequency applications, although they come at a higher cost than other materials.

• Hybrid PCBs

Hybrid PCBs combine different base materials on a single board to achieve optimal performance tailored to specific use cases. Known for their flexibility and adaptability, they increase design and manufacturing complexities, potentially leading to higher costs for custom solutions.

• Thick Copper PCBs

Thick Copper PCBs feature copper layers exceeding 3 ounces (105µm), making them ideal for high-current applications where power distribution and heat dissipation are critical. Enhanced current-carrying capacity and improved heat dissipation are notable benefits, though they may be excessive and more costly for many low-power projects.

Are you interested in learning more about NiCr Alloy? Contact us today to secure an expert consultation!

Additional reading:
NiCr 8020 alloy

• Copper-Invar-Copper (CIC) PCBs

Combining copper with invar, a material with a low coefficient of thermal expansion, results in CIC PCBs. These excel in high-precision applications where dimensional stability is essential. Their primary advantage is dimensional stability over a wide temperature range, though they offer limited flexibility and are more costly than other PCB materials.

Factors to Consider When Selecting PCB Materials

Consider the thermal, mechanical, electrical, and chemical properties of materials to choose the best fit for your application.

Thermally, consider the temperature durability of the components and their optimal functioning temperatures. For mechanical properties, think about enclosure, form factor control, and density, especially relevant for rigid-flex PCBs.

Electrical properties are critical for balancing dielectric requirements like impedance, signal quality, and resistances. Chemical considerations, such as moisture absorption and flammability, are also crucial for proper PCB performance.

Ideal for Multilayer PCBs

Multilayering, or stacking board layers, saves space. Consider dimensional and electrical features while designing multilayer PCBs. The following materials are suitable for multilayer boards:

RO4000: Known for its low-thermal coefficient dielectric constant, reducing phase variations and closely related to copper in the CTE z-axis, making it ideal for multilayer boards.

Flex-rigid materials: RO3000 materials are excellent for low-loss microwave boards but not in multilayer boards because of their dimensional and dielectric changes with temperature. However, they can perform well in multilayer PCBs by combining electrical properties with the mechanical elements of polyimide materials.

PCB Materials to Use in High-Frequency Boards

High-frequency applications, including wireless connections, high speeds, and frequencies, necessitate PCBs made from materials that maintain signal strength and minimize interference. The following materials are ideal for high-frequency PCBs:

Fluorine-series resin: PTFE materials display high dielectric performance and are suitable for making 5GHz frequency boards. Although expensive and with high-temperature expansion coefficients, they perform well in high dielectric loss and humid conditions.

PPO or PPE resin: Suitable for PCBs operating at 1-10GHz frequencies, providing reliable performance throughout their lifespan.

Modified epoxy resin: Ideal for creating boards at 1-10GHz frequencies, these materials are the most economical among high-frequency PCB materials.

How to Choose the Right Materials for High-Frequency Applications?

1. Matching the CTE properties: Ensure that the CTE between two materials matches to prevent substrate expansion at varying speeds and uniformities, which can cause defects during manufacturing.
2. Tight material weave: Weave materials appropriately for better interaction with the mesh.
3. Matching the dielectric constants: Mismatched Dk values can cause issues; thus, pairing materials correctly is essential.
4. FR-4 is not an alternative: FR-4 material is unsuitable for high-frequency boards. While some designers use it due to its low cost, they risk